Supreme Court of India · 2012
M.S.R. Leathers v. S. Palaniappan
(2013) 1 SCC 177 · Criminal Appeal Nos. 261–264 of 2002
Court
Supreme Court of India
Bench
R.M. Lodha, T.S. Thakur & Anil R. Dave, JJ.
Date
26 September 2012
Subject
NI Act — Successive Dishonour of the Same Cheque
Background & Facts
The question in MSR Leathers was whether the payee of a cheque may prosecute the drawer under Section 138 of the NI Act on the basis of a second or later dishonour of the same cheque, when no complaint was filed on an earlier dishonour that had been followed by a statutory notice and non-payment. In Sadanandan Bhadran v. Madhavan Sunil Kumar (1998) 6 SCC 514, the Supreme Court had held that the cause of action under Section 142(b) can arise only once, so such a complaint was not maintainable. A two-Judge Bench (Markandey Katju and B. Sudershan Reddy, JJ.) doubted that view and referred the question to a larger Bench.
On the facts, the respondent company issued four cheques for a total of Rs.10 lakh on 14 August 1996 in favour of the appellant, MSR Leathers. They were dishonoured for insufficiency of funds on presentation in November 1996, and a notice under clause (b) of the proviso to Section 138 was issued on 8 January 1997, but no payment was made. According to the appellant, the respondent assured it that funds would be made available, and the cheques were presented again on 21 January 1997 and dishonoured again. A fresh statutory notice dated 28 January 1997 was received on 3 February 1997; on non-payment, the appellant filed complaints before the II Metropolitan Magistrate, Madras. The Magistrate refused to discharge the accused, but the Madras High Court quashed the Magistrate's orders relying on Sadanandan Bhadran.
Key Issue Before the Court
Holdings of the Court
Holding 1 — Sadanandan Bhadran Overruled
The three-Judge Bench (judgment by T.S. Thakur, J.) concluded: “we overrule the decision in Sadanandan Bhadran's case (supra) and hold that prosecution based upon second or successive dishonour of the cheque is also permissible so long as the same satisfies the requirements stipulated in the proviso to Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act” (para 33).
Holding 2 — The Cheque May Be Presented Any Number of Times Within Its Validity
The Court noted that neither Section 138 nor Section 142, nor any other provision of the Act, forbids the holder or payee from presenting the cheque for encashment on any number of occasions within six months of its issue or within the period of its validity, whichever is earlier (para 13).
Holding 3 — Section 142(b) Does Not Bar Prosecution on a Later Default
While a complaint based on a default and notice must be filed within one month of the date the cause of action accrues, “there is nothing in Section 142 to suggest that expiry of any such limitation would absolve him of his criminal liability should the cheque continue to get dishonoured by the bank on subsequent presentations”. So long as the cheque is valid and is dishonoured on presentation, the holder's right to prosecute the drawer for the default remains valid and exercisable (para 23).
Holding 4 — Deferring Prosecution to Allow Payment Does Not Absolve the Drawer
The Court saw “no real or qualitative difference” between a case where prosecution is launched immediately on default and one where it is deferred until the cheque, presented again, is dishonoured a second or successive time (para 31). An interpretation that forced payees to launch complaints on the first default, instead of extending accommodation to the drawer to arrange payment, was to be avoided, and the Court observed that the law declared in Sadanandan Bhadran had added to court congestion (para 32).
Outcome
The reference was answered and the appeals were sent back to the regular Bench. On 10 September 2013, a Bench of K.S. Radhakrishnan and Pinaki Chandra Ghose, JJ. set aside the Madras High Court's order and allowed the appeals in light of the larger Bench's decision.
Practical Implications
A payee who issued a statutory notice after the first dishonour, but deferred prosecution (for example, on the drawer's assurance of payment), is not shut out from prosecuting on a later dishonour of the same cheque. The later dishonour must itself satisfy each condition of the proviso to Section 138.
Under the enacted text, the cheque must be presented within six months from the date on which it is drawn or within the period of its validity, whichever is earlier; the demand notice must be given within thirty days of receipt of the bank's information about the return of the cheque as unpaid; the drawer must have failed to pay within fifteen days of receipt of the notice; and the complaint must be made within one month of the date on which the cause of action arises under clause (c) of the proviso (Section 142(1)(b)), subject to the court's power to condone delay for sufficient cause.
Relevant Statutory Provisions
Practical Application for Creditors & Borrowers
Creditors dealing with a cheque that has been dishonoured more than once, or businesses managing Section 138 portfolio recovery, need the timeline for each dishonour, notice and complaint mapped carefully. Unified Chambers advises on Section 138 complaints and recovery strategy.
Related Judgments: