Supreme Court of India · 2017
N. Harihara Krishnan v. J. Thomas
(2018) 13 SCC 663 · AIR 2017 SC 4125 · Criminal Appeal No. 1534 of 2017
Court
Supreme Court of India
Bench
J. Chelameswar & S. Abdul Nazeer, JJ.
Decided
30 August 2017
Subject
NI Act — Drawer, Company Accused, S.142 Limitation
Background and Facts
The respondent filed a complaint on 8 October 2012 before the VII Metropolitan Magistrate, George Town, Chennai, against the appellant alone, alleging that he drew a cheque for Rs.39 lakh towards the balance sale consideration for three parcels of land. The cheque was dishonoured on the ground that the account had been closed, and a statutory notice was issued on 10 September 2012.
The cheque was in fact drawn on the account of a company, Dakshin Granites Pvt. Ltd., of which the appellant was a director. On 19 August 2015, about three years later, the respondent applied under Section 319 CrPC to implead the company as an accused, claiming he had learnt during the appellant's cross-examination that the cheque was drawn on the company's account. The Magistrate allowed the application and the Madras High Court dismissed the appellant's revision. The Supreme Court also noted (para 9) that the three sale deeds recorded a total consideration of Rs.6,50,000, so that it was “very doubtful” whether the Rs.39 lakh cheque was drawn for any amount legally due.
The Statutory Framework — Sections 141 and 142
Cognizance and Offences by Companies
Section 142(1)(b) requires the complaint to be made within one month of the date on which the cause of action arises under clause (c) of the proviso to Section 138, though the court may take cognizance after that period if the complainant satisfies it that he had sufficient cause for the delay. Section 141(1) provides that where the person committing the Section 138 offence is a company, every person who was in charge of and responsible to the company for the conduct of its business, “as well as the company”, shall be deemed to be guilty of the offence.
Key Holdings of the Court
Holding 1 — Only the Drawer Commits the Offence; a Signatory Is Not the Drawer
“The offence under Section 138 of THE ACT is capable of being committed only by the drawer of the cheque” (para 20). “Every person signing a cheque on behalf of a company on whose account a cheque is drawn does not become the drawer of the cheque”; such a signatory is only a person authorised to sign on behalf of the company/drawer, and his liability, if any, is statutory, arising from his status as director (para 21).
Holding 2 — The Company Must Be Arraigned (Aneeta Hada)
Applying Aneeta Hada v. Godfather Travels & Tours (P) Ltd. (2012) 5 SCC 661, which held that “for maintaining the prosecution under Section 141 of the Act, arraigning of a company as an accused is imperative”, the Court held that the director-signatory was entitled to object to the company being summoned beyond the limitation period even though the company itself had not challenged its summoning (para 21).
Holding 3 — Section 138 Is “Person Specific”; Cognizance of the Offence Alone Is Not Enough
The general CrPC principle that a court takes cognizance of the offence and not the offender (Raghubans Dubey v. State of Bihar, AIR 1967 SC 1167) does not fit a Section 138 prosecution, which has no investigation stage and proceeds on the payee's complaint. “In the context of a prosecution under Section 138, the concept of taking cognizance of the offence but not the offender is not appropriate.” The complaint must disclose the drawer; “There cannot be a prosecution without an accused. The offence under Section 138 is person specific” (para 24).
Holding 4 — Section 319 CrPC Cannot Be Used to Evade Limitation
The Section 319 application was “only a device by which the respondent seeks to initiate prosecution against DAKSHIN beyond the period of limitation stipulated under the Act” (para 25). Section 142 permits condonation in appropriate cases, but the Court found no reason to condone the delay: the claim of discovering the drawer only during trial was “a manifestly false statement”, because the face of the cheque showed the company's account and the respondent had sent the statutory notice to the company (para 26). The appeal was allowed, the High Court's judgment set aside, and costs of Rs.1,00,000 quantified (para 27).
Practical Implications for Practitioners
For complainants, the judgment is a reminder to identify the drawer from the face of the cheque before filing. Where the cheque is drawn on a company's account, the company must be named as an accused in the complaint filed within the Section 142(1)(b) period; prosecuting only the director who signed it is not maintainable, and adding the company later through Section 319 CrPC will not cure a time-barred prosecution.
For directors and signatories, the judgment confirms that a signatory is not the drawer, and that a prosecution against the signatory alone, without the company being arraigned, can be challenged on the authority of Aneeta Hada.
Authorities Discussed in the Judgment
Relevant Statutory Provisions
Facing a Cheque Bounce Case?
Unified Chambers and Associates handles Section 138 NI Act prosecutions and defences. Our partner-led team advises on enforcement strategy for creditors and defence strategy for accused directors and companies.